from Nick Paretsky,
Some radical leftists are probably trying to figure out to relate to an
Obama presidency and understand the significance of the first
African-American President in history for an analysis that has made the
institution of white supremacy a critically defining feature of
American capitalism. There may be some disorientation on the left. Many
on the Left no doubt look to an Obama presidency as creating an opening
for progressive change, e.g., Howard Zinn’s piece at Znet, “Obama’s
Historic Victory.” At CounterPunch.org you can find more skeptical, and
maybe more realistic appraisals of the Obama candidacy and the shape of
his coming administration.
To MAR: So, what are your thoughts? (I’m not a member of BTR or 3-W-F,
incidentally.) Are you being sarcastic when you say Obama’s election
represents a “vibrant exercise of multi-racial democracy”? And what is
a “Middle American Radical”?
Another way of thinking about this claim about Obama and “multi-racial
democracy” can be found in J. Sakai’s argument about the
“desettlerization” of U.S. empire, in his essay, “The Shock of
Recognition,” in the collection, Confronting Fascism, written as a
response to D Hamerquist’s, “Fascism & Anti-Fascism.” Sakai sees a
transnationalization, or globalization of the “U.S.” empire which is
partly registered by the growing presence of people of color in high
levels of the state apparatus – e.g., Rice, Powell, and others in the
Bush Administration. He argues that this globalization of empire is
disrupting the system of white-skin privilege, which creates the
potential for a white fascist mass movement: while white preference
will be around for a long time, “the big guys are sending a message
down to ordinary white men. It’s like a bomb. In the new globalized
multicularal capitalism…the provincial, sheltered white settler life of
America is going to be as over as the white settler life of the South
African 'Afrikaners’ is” (pp.96-97).
Sakai’s reasoning about globalization's undermining of white
privileges, and fascism, is in accord with a lot of what’s been said on
on 3-W-F. Sakai also makes me think of Obama in terms of this new,
“multicultural, globalized capitalism.” (I put US in quotation marks
above because of the view, advanced by Hamerquist, that a global ruling
class is ascendant and that the concept of “US imperialism” is
increasingly inadequate in a globalized capitalism. Hamerquist’s
position is of course also controversial.)
AN INSURGENT BLOG ON THE STRUGGLE AGAINST THE STATE AND FASCISM
CONTACT
email: threewayfight [at] gmail [dot] com
POPULAR POSTS
- Calling them "alt-right" helps us fight them
- Jack Donovan on men: a masculine tribalism for the far right
- Moscow conference draws fascists, neo-Confederates, U.S. leftists
- Major report on red-brown alliances from new anarchist website
- Rightists woo the Occupy Wall Street movement
- Broken windows fascism
- Network Contagion Research Institute: helping the state fight political infection left and right
- Alt-right: more misogynistic than many neonazis
- Seven Theses on the Three-Way Fight
- AlternativeRight.com: Paleoconservatism for the 21st Century
DOCUMENTS (mostly on other sites)
- An American National Bolshevik (Loren Goldner)
- Anti-Repression, Anti-Fascist Strategizing Suggestions (mamos206)
- Anti-Semitism and the Revolutionary Right (Kersplebedeb)
- Barack, Badiou, and Bilal al Hasan (Don Hamerquist)
- Ecofascism: Lessons from the German Experience (Janet Biehl and Peter Staudenmaier)
- Exodus and Reconstruction: Working-Class Women at the Heart of Globalization (Bromma)
- Fascism & Anti-Fascism (Don Hamerquist)
- For Women Only: After Anti-War Movements win or lose in Iraq...there's still Women (Butch Lee)
- Notes on Women and Right-Wing Movements (Matthew Lyons)
- The Shock of Recognition (J. Sakai)
- Two Ways of Looking at Fascism (Matthew Lyons)
BLOG ARCHIVE
-
▼
2008
(79)
-
▼
November
(11)
- Discussion on, A Call: Build Popular Power Bloc at...
- Expose 'Em, Out 'Em: Portland, Oregon Nazis on dis...
- Woman slain as she tried to leave KKK ceremony
- Leaked BNP Member List Map
- Fallout from published BNP membership list
- Entire BNP membership list goes online
- Defend Polish Antifascists
- Ruling Class thinking Pt.2
- ...something on the election
- Ruling Class thinking on the makings of future rev...
- Election spurs 'hundreds' of race threats, crimes
-
▼
November
(11)
Powered by Blogger.
1 comments:
I want to qualify some of my remarks – maybe backpedal is more accurate. I still think Sakai is on to something with his notion of the "desettlerization of empire.” But I don’t agree with everything in J. Sakai’s general perspective on the American white working class as it’s presented in his book, “Settlers,” and I think the analogy of white workers in the US with the Afrikaners in the above quotation is overdrawn. (Among other things, in “Settlers,” I remember that he seems to deny the existence of a white working class. In an interview he tried to clarify this view by acknowledging that there are indeed “millions” of white workers, but somehow they did not qualify as being members of the proletariat. I don’t understand how he sees the relation between the concepts of “working class” and “proletariat.” It’s been a while since I read “Settlers” so I need to look at his writings again to avoid distorting his positions.)
I also may sound too dismissive of the anti-racist and historic signficance of there being an African American first family in the White House. It was a major mobilization of blacks at the polls that help put him in office, so there was a mass, black activism at work. Many whites were willing to shed their “Afrikaner” outlook and voted for him. Many young whites were inspired by his campaign, and that’s a good thing. His election, as Doug Henwood and others point out, demonstrates a desire for real social change in the country, even if an Obama adminstration can’t deliver.
I also want to apologize for the unnecessarily confrontational tone of my comments to the Middle American Radical, “anonymous.”
I wish I could have shared in the excitement at the election of Barak Obama to be President of the United Snakes of America. Something in my gut says it came to late in the history of US capitalism for it have the liberatory meaning it might have once had. As I’ve grown older I’ve become more jaded, numb, about electoral politics, regardless of the candidate. Seattle in ‘99 and the LA rebellion of ‘92 were more electrifying for me.
Nick Paretsky
Post a Comment